Just finished Season 1 and 2x01 tonight!
I wanted to say: I love Ellie & Captain Awesome. I feel like they're characters on
Scrubs who have been transplanted into the wrong sitcom, but are making due with what they've got.
Scrubs is in So Cal too; so I'm absolutely convinced they work in the same hospital. I want to see Awesome vs. Janitor.
*has only watched the first 5 seasons of Scrubs and is nearly completely unspoiled past that*
Other comments:
Chuck is light, cheesy, popcorn fun. It's not as delectable or anywhere near as inventive as
Pushing Daisies, and it's not quite as whackily addicting as
Doctor Who. But it's charming enough and I plan to sail right through season 2 this week. If anything, it reminds me of
Psych and
Monk, but with a bigger budget and not quite as irreverent. What does that mean? It means it's a feel-good, candyfloss show that I can watch and come out of the experience with at least a few smiles, and the guarantee that all's well that ends well. That's not the worst to ask for in a tv show.
As far as characters go: Chuck is alright, but he annoys me sometimes. Not with his ineptitude, which makes sense and is only human, but with the way he seems to revel in his own weakness. He clings to his lack of training and his clumsiness and his "I'm only a civilian!" attitude as a way to cling to his normal life, but after a little while it starts to get unbelievable. Chuck isn't like
Farscape'sJohn Crichton--he doesn't seem to have the mindset to start carrying guns around and actually LEARN how to fight, or even the will to try, until the very end of season 1. He clings to normalcy to the point where he's not trying to
learn anything from Casey or Sarah, like John has over time been learning from Aeryn and D'Argo. If it were me, I'd be screaming "OH MY GOD, TEACH ME HOW TO DEFEND MYSELF IF THESE SITUATIONS KEEP HAPPENING! PLEASE!" after the first two near-death experiences.
Sarah: I like Sarah and Chuck both a lot more when they're working and not mooning over each other, especially Sarah. They really overwrite the romance to the point where it detracts from the adventure, and it detracts from both characters. But generally I like Sarah a lot, and the actress does a good job even if the material gets cheek-biting sappy. She certainly carries herself like a femme fatale, which is what the part needs.
Casey: Honestly, Casey is the reason I'm watching this show from the start instead of just picking it up when the new season begins. Adam Baldwin is hilariously fun to watch no matter what, but I really like him here. I like that he's an unrepentent killer who's almost made into a moral person by pure, unfiltered exposure to Chuck's innocence. Saving Chuck and working at the Buy More seems to have introduced mundanity back into Casey's world view, and the result is that he finds his world view expanding to new and uncomfortable levels. I like how much he's gotten into selling, and I loved how he was in the season 2 premier. His whole half of the "catch me when I fall" converation, and its callback in the fight scene later, were hilariously played. In many ways I think Casey's almost a better handler than Sarah; her strength is infiltration but he seems the more reliable man-on-the-ground.
Casey and Sarah working together, especially when Chuck's somewhere else, is AWESOME FUN TIMES. I loved when she called him her partner and he was all surprised and touched by it.
The episode about Casey's girlfriend was by FAR the most enjoyable for me of season 1. Not only was it funny, fun to watch, and let the actor have lots of meaty material the writers usually force on Sarah and Chuck, but we got to see Chuck and Sarah doing their jobs without too much uncomfortable forced romance written into the plot! Sarah did her thing and Chuck got to be a good friend to Casey and Casey had all the big character revelations and it was a hoot all around.
I also enjoyed the helicopter flying sequence, the subplot of Awesome and Ellie's relationship problems and its resolution (with Awesome coming to Chuck for help, LOL), and the way they made Morgan drop a solid 40% in irritation factor by having Anna make him her boyfriend.
Things I could do with less of:
- The two annoying/disgusting guys at the BuyMore.
- Irrelevent BuyMore subplots that are clearly filler and often have no connection to main adventure plot. When the two are intertwined, like the theft of the marlin & merchandise beside Chuck's indentity risk, it works well. When they're separate, I just as often skip to the end of the scene. Especially if its got Lester and Jeff, who both repulse me.
- Chuck & Sarah reinacting season 1 of Fushigi Yuugi: "Tamahome!" "Miaka!" "Tamahome!" "Miaka!" "TAMAHOME!!!!!!!!" "MIAKA!!!!!!!"
- Chuck's terrible excuses for things. His inability to make up shit and lie well enough to pass for truth (and NOT destroy his relationships at the same time) sometimes reaches sitcom levels of silliness.
- Bryce as Chuck's rival for Sarah's love. Bryce was an okay character, but I'd hate to see him overused just for romantic tension.